Search this Site:

News latest

Oh, This? I Just Threw It Together

I have, on several many occasions, been described as a man who looks effortlessly relaxed. I would like to take this opportunity to confirm that it is entirely true. I have never practised it, never rehearsed it, and have certainly never held a pose in a corridor waiting for somebody to walk past. An ex-Director does not do that. An ex-Director simply arrives, unhurried and serene, as though the day had been arranged around him in advance. The fact that one hand is, at that moment, gripping a bunch of keys so tightly that they leave a mark is, of course, nobody’s business but mine and the keys’.

My attentive dear reader will have noticed that I protested too much there, and that the keys gave me away. Quite so. Effortlessness is very rarely effortless. It is effort that has been moved out of sight, and almost everyone who looks calm is, somewhere beneath the surface, paddling furiously. This, I think, is the human condition in miniature.

Now, this has been the week in which we were Ofsteded for two days, which means as I write these paltry words, there is an elephant in the Director’s room.  The elephant is large, it is grey, and any columnist in my position would be expected to write about it. I have been walking round it with great composure, in the manner of somebody who has not noticed an elephant, and, dear reader, I intend to carry on. I shall give it the polite nod one gives a visitor on the way out, with a firm handshake and a warm do come again, and then say nothing more about those two days… partly because the rest is not mine to say, and partly because the interesting question is not about us at all. It is about what happens to anyone, when they know that they are being seen. 

What I noticed, walking round, was a whole community going about its day with remarkable composure. Doors were held. Corridors were quiet. The lunch queue was a model of civilisation. It was like watching a swan, serene above the waterline and furiously busy beneath it.

The Italians, of course, have a better word for this phenomenon than ‘swan’.

In 1528, Baldassare Castiglione published The Book of the Courtier, a guide for the ambitious young person hoping to survive a Renaissance court. Its central instruction is sprezzatura, usually translated as studied nonchalance: the art of doing difficult things so gracefully that nobody can see the effort. The ideal courtier must dance, fence, compose verse and flatter his prince, all while giving the impression that he has just wandered in from the garden. The art, Castiglione says, is to conceal the art.

It is wonderful advice and, if you think about it for longer than two seconds, slightly mad. You are being asked to work extremely hard at appearing not to have worked at all. Everyone who has hosted a dinner party will recognise the technique. Oh, this? I just threw it together. The reality is of course that the lasagne has been in preparation since last Tuesday, and there is a second, backup lasagne in the fridge just in case.

Some four and a half centuries after The Book of the Courtier, the critic Stephen Greenblatt gave the idea a name that has launched a thousand A Level essays: self-fashioning. His argument, put simply, is that in the sixteenth century identity was less something you discovered inside yourself than something you built in public, out of manners, clothes, speech, loyalty and wit. I find this both liberating and faintly alarming. Liberating, because nobody is stuck with the version of themselves they were at fourteen. Alarming, because at a court everyone is watching, and a bad day goes on the record.

Shakespeare, who spent his career among people reading one another like menus, is wonderful on what all this costs. Consider Polonius, who sends his son Laertes off to Paris with the most quoted advice about authenticity in the English language, This above all: to thine own self be true. It is a lovely line. It is also delivered by a man who, a couple of scenes later, sends a servant to Paris to spy on the same son. Polonius believes absolutely in being true to yourself, provided somebody is checking. Your ex-Director would never send a servant to Paris, of course, but I do confess to a fondness for the sort of advice that is much better given than taken.

And then there is Malvolio, who is what happens when self-fashioning slips its lead. Persuaded that the Lady Olivia secretly adores him, he reinvents himself in a single afternoon: yellow stockings, cross-gartered, smiling at everybody with the fixed and appalling cheerfulness of a man who has followed the instructions to the letter. It is one of the funniest scenes in English drama, and one of the cruellest, because the performance is watched from behind a box tree by people who know precisely how much effort he is making. We laugh, and then hopefully we remember our own version of those cross-garters. Mine were a pair of spectacularly ambitious trousers paraded at a wedding in 2009. I shall not elaborate.

The twentieth century put all of this in a sociology textbook. In The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life, Erving Goffman argued that ordinary social life is a kind of theatre, with a front stage where we perform for others and a back stage where we drop the act and put our feet up. The waiter glides through the dining room, smooth and serene, then pushes through the kitchen door and becomes a rather different person, with a rather different vocabulary. None of us is exempt. The lecture hall has its green room, the courtroom its robing room, and even the most composed of public figures is, at some point in the day, grateful for a door that closes. Goffman’s insight is that this is not hypocrisy. It is simply how a social life is organised: we need somewhere to prepare, and somewhere to recover.

It was, unsurprisingly, old friend of the Column, Jean-Paul Sartre who made Goffman’s cheerful theatre uncomfortable. In Being and Nothingness, he describes a café waiter whose every movement is a fraction too precise, too eager, too thoroughly waiterly, as if he were trying to convince himself, and us, that this is what he is. Sartre calls this acting in bad faith: pretending we are simply the part we play, rather than free people choosing to play it. And why do we reach so eagerly for the costume? Because of what Sartre calls the look. The moment I realise that someone is looking at me, I stop being the one who looks at the world and become an object in somebody else’s: a person with a posture, a face and a possible flaw. Most of us know this in the body long before we have the words for it. It is the hot ears of the child chosen to read aloud. It is the sudden, treacherous awareness of one’s own hands. Sartre’s name for it is shame, and he does not mean the shame of having done something wrong. He means the dizzying recognition that one is seen, and that the seeing is not under one’s control. Another old friend of the Column, George Orwell, knew a thing or two about being looked at, and about elephants. In his 1936 essay Shooting an Elephant, he describes standing before a crowd of two thousand people, forced to play the part expected of him simply to avoid looking like a fool. He wears a mask, Orwell writes, and his face grows to fit it. It is a chilling thought when the crowd is demanding something you do not wish to give.

Fitzgerald also understood this well. James Gatz, a farm boy from North Dakota, decides at seventeen to become Jay Gatsby, and performs the role so thoroughly that it becomes the most beautiful and fragile thing in the novel. What makes him tragic is not that he is a fraud. It is that the whole glittering performance is addressed to one person, who is, for much of the time, looking at the wrong bit of it.

In A Doll’s House, Nora Helmer dances the tarantella to the delight of an audience that includes her husband, while her real life quietly collapses elsewhere. Ibsen shows us that the people who applaud the performance are often the last to ask who is performing.  Sylvia Plath, a century later, gives us a speaker who turns her own suffering into a spectacle for a jostling crowd, and who knows exactly what she is doing and exactly what it costs. Both ask the same question: what is left of us once the audience goes home?

Then comes the trap that catches the well-meaning. We are often told it is a good idea to be authentic, an excellent instruction apart from the fact that it cannot be followed. An instruction to be spontaneous is self-defeating, and an attempt to look natural is simply another performance, as your ex-Director’s own claim to effortless calm, keys and all, rather demonstrates.

Nowadays we must sadly add one further complication. Every generation has been looked at, but none quite like this one. For most of history, a blunder had a small audience and a short memory. Today’s teenagers carry in their pockets something very like a Renaissance court: a permanent audience with instant verdicts, in which every outfit and haircut is an act of self-fashioning that may be screenshotted and resurface at a family wedding. Castiglione at least had the decency to hold his court in the evenings. If a child arrives on a Monday with the grey, hollowed look of someone who has been performing since Friday, that is probably exactly what they have been doing.

So what do we do about it? I do not think the answer is to stop performing. We could not, and we would be poorer for it. The better question is whether there is somewhere to stop. Goffman’s back stage is not a luxury. It is where we are restored, and a person with no back stage is a person with no rest. What I would wish for every child in this school, and every adult, is a few people in whose company they do not have to do anything. A gaze that does not grade or rank or ask for a better version. A look, if I may borrow Sartre’s word and turn it round, that does not make you an object but leaves you a person. Parents and teachers can offer this when we are at our best, and I think it is most of what we are for.

Which brings me, finally, to your ex-Director. It would be easy to end by saying that the man who writes this column is a front-stage creation, and that the real one is somewhere else, ignoring elephants. But I do not think that is true, and I do not think it is true of any of us. Your ex-Director is as real as you are. He is made of the same materials: habits, manners, aspirations, the odd borrowed phrase, and a tone of voice he has been refining since about 1987. That he is assembled does not make him false. It makes him a person.

The word itself is worth a glance. Person very probably comes from the Latin persona, the mask worn by an actor on the Roman stage, and the connection is too good to ignore even if the etymologists argue about it. Wilde, who knew a thing or two about this, said that a man is least himself when he speaks in his own person, and that if you give him a mask he will tell you the truth. I find that rather hopeful. The performance is often where the truth gets said.

And that is the good news, if we want it. We cannot stop being seen, and we cannot stop shaping how we are seen, so the real question is what we choose to perform. Aristotle, in the Nicomachean Ethics, has the sensible, unglamorous answer: we do not wait to feel virtuous before we act well; we become just by doing just acts, brave by doing brave ones. A kind person is performing kindness until it becomes who they are. A patient teacher is practising patience in front of thirty fourteen-year-olds until it holds. A child who stands up to read aloud, hot-eared and appalled, is learning to be the person who can. Sprezzatura, at its best, is not a lie but an aspiration made visible. You act the part of who you are becoming, and, on several many occasions, you turn out to have been right.

So the next time you see your ex-Director looking effortlessly relaxed, I would ask you to read it generously: as a performance given in good faith by someone who is, somewhere beneath it, paddling like mad, and who is doing it for the sake of the people in the room. The keys will be gripped. The elephant will be politely ignored. Both, I think, are signs of a person doing his best.

Have a restful weekend. And if you find yourself at the school gate on Monday performing slightly too hard, do come and stand next to me. We can be unconvincing together. The elephant, I am told, has already left, and I’m told, won’t be back for a while.

Until next time, Happy reading / sprezzaturing!